Saltar al contenido principal
Islamic Portal
Únete gratisÚnete
Islamic Portal
Explóralo todo
Tema
Esta página aún no está disponible en tu idioma, por eso se muestra en inglés. Leer la página en inglés

Herencia islámica · Tema 11 de 13

Differences Among the Schools

Where the Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali schools differ

The four Sunni schools agree on most of inheritance, because its shares come from clear verses. They differ on a number of important questions, and a qualified scholar will apply the position of the school your community follows, or of your country's Islamic courts.

The grandfather with brothers and sisters

Dictamen

One of the best-known differences

Abu Hanifah held that the paternal grandfather takes the father's place and excludes brothers and sisters. The Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali schools, with Abu Hanifah's two companions Abu Yusuf and Muhammad al-Shaybani, hold that full and paternal siblings share with the grandfather under detailed conditions. Because of this, our calculator does not handle a grandfather.

Radd and distant relatives

Dictamen

What happens to a surplus

The Hanafi and Hanbali schools return a surplus to the sharers (radd) and, failing them, give the estate to distant relatives (dhawu al-arham). The early Maliki and Shafi'i positions gave it to the public treasury; later scholars of both schools allowed radd and inheritance by distant relatives where there is no properly run treasury. A spouse alone receives the surplus by radd in the view of some later scholars.

Other differences

Killing, debts to Allah and special cases

The schools also differ on which kinds of killing prevent inheritance, on whether unpaid zakat is taken from the estate, and on a number of special cases studied by specialists. These differences are one reason why every real estate should be reviewed by a qualified scholar.

Solo con fines educativos. Un reparto calculado o resuelto no es asesoramiento jurídico ni significa que cumpla la legislación de tu país. Consulta a un erudito cualificado en herencia y, cuando se aplique el derecho civil, a un abogado.

¿Y ahora qué?

Sigue aprendiendo sobre la herencia