Phase 3 — Years of missed prayers, and differences of opinion
Travel across the schools
- 11 min
- Gratuit — sans inscription
Four schools, one journey
Travel across the schools (broadly)
Why the schools come out differently
The Quran gives the permission to shorten, and the Prophet ﷺ shortened on every journey. The schools then had to answer practical questions: how far is a journey, how long a stay ends it, and is shortening a duty or a permission?
The Hanafi school made it a duty, with fifteen days ending travel. Others answered differently. All are sound; you keep your school's answers.
Why they differ
Praying together on the trip
Your Shafi'i friend wants to pray Asr in Dhuhr's time. In the Hanafi school, Asr before its time is not valid. So pray Dhuhr together, then pray your Asr when its time comes, perhaps together again at the next stop.
Your friend may follow you, too: shortening is allowed in every school. Agree the plan before you set off, and there is no awkwardness on the road.
On the group trip
Hanafi or others?
Distance and days, simply
The Hanafi travel distance is a three days' journey at the old pace of walking and camels, which scholars today give as about 78 km (48 miles). The other schools measure four barīd, about 80 to 89 km.
A stay ends travel at fifteen days intended in the Hanafi school, and about four in the others. Same journey, different counts: each school's followers keep their own.
Check your understanding
Who prays how?
Pause and think
Four schools, one journey, and all of them sincere. How can you travel with friends of another school with grace?
Privé : conservé uniquement dans ce navigateur, jamais envoyé chez nous.
Common mistakes
In short
- Hanafi: about 78 km, shortening obligatory, fifteen days ends travel, no combining on journeys.
- Others: about 80 to 89 km, shortening allowed, about four days, combining allowed.
- Asr before its time is not valid for a Hanafi.
- Plan prayers together before the trip.
Try it today
On your next group trip, agree beforehand how you will pray together, with respect for each school.
