The Rightly Guided Caliphs · Beginner · Lesson 2/3 Four caliphs, about thirty years

Step inside

Madinah and Kufah, 632 to 661

Four leaders, four ways

Four caliphs in about thirty years, each chosen a different way, all by consultation.

Look

Four leaders, four ways

Four tiles for four ways a caliph was chosen: at the Saqifah, by nomination, by a council of six, by pledge in Madinah

Imagine a country that changes its leader four times in thirty years. Each time the leader is chosen in a different way, and each way is accepted by the people.

That is the story of the first caliphate. It shows that Islam set principles for choosing leaders, consultation and the people’s pledge, rather than one fixed method.

Timeline

The four caliphs

  1. 11–13 AH (632–634 CE)
    Abu Bakr as-Siddiq

    Chosen at the Saqifah. Holds Arabia together and gathers the Quran.

    ⌖ Madinah
  2. 13–23 AH (634–644)
    ’Umar ibn al-Khattab

    Named by Abu Bakr after consultation. Sham, Iraq, Egypt and Persia open.

    ⌖ Madinah
  3. 24–35 AH (644–656)
    ’Uthman ibn ’Affan

    Chosen by a council of six. One mushaf sent to every land.

    ⌖ Madinah
  4. 35–40 AH (656–661)
    ’Ali ibn Abi Talib

    Pledged to in Madinah during a crisis. Rules from Kufah.

    ⌖ Kufah
  5. 40–41 AH (661)
    Al-Hasan ibn ’Ali

    About six months, then makes peace for the sake of unity.

    ⌖ Kufah

Side by side

How each was chosen

Caliph How he was chosen Who agreed
Abu Bakr Discussion at the Saqifah, then the pledge The Muhajirun and Ansar, then all Madinah
’Umar Named by Abu Bakr after he consulted senior companions The people pledged after Abu Bakr died
’Uthman A council of six named by ’Umar; ’Abd al-Rahman ibn ’Awf asked the people The council and the people of Madinah
’Ali Pledged to in Madinah after ’Uthman was killed Most of Madinah; others waited for justice first

Word by word

Their affairs by consultation

﴿38﴾
  1. وَٱلَّذِينَ walladhīna those who (masculine plural)
  2. ٱسْتَجَابُوا۟ istajābū
  3. لِرَبِّهِمْ lirabbihim Lord: the one who owns, nurtures, provides for and cares for · ربب
  4. وَأَقَامُوا۟ waʾaqāmū
  5. ٱلصَّلَوٰةَ aṣ-ṣalawāta prayer (the ritual prayer) · صلو
  6. وَأَمْرُهُمْ waʾamruhum command; matter, affair · أمر
  7. شُورَىٰ shūrā
  8. بَيْنَهُمْ baynahum between, among; bayna yadayhi: before it, ahead of it · بين
  9. وَمِمَّا wamimmā from, of, out of, some of
  10. رَزَقْنَٰهُمْ razaqnāhum to provide (for) · رزق
  11. يُنفِقُونَ yunfiqūna to spend (in charity, for a good cause) · نفق

And those who answer the call of their Lord and establish worship, and whose affairs are a matter of counsel, and who spend of what We have bestowed on them,

Ash-Shuraa 42:38 · Marmaduke Pickthall (en.pickthall)

Look

The principle behind the methods

A low round table with cushions and an open scroll: consultation before decisions

The verse places shura (consultation) beside prayer and charity, as part of the believers’ character, not just a rule for rulers.

Every caliph was chosen through some form of shura and a public bay’ah. No one simply seized power. You can see the same spirit when a family talks a big decision through before acting.

Read

Abu Bakr names ’Umar

A circle of cushions on a mat under a palm-frond roof, a place to sit and take counsel

In his last illness, in 13 AH, Abu Bakr feared a quarrel after him. He asked senior companions about ’Umar, among them ’Abd ar-Rahman ibn ’Awf and ’Uthman. Some worried that ’Umar was too stern. Abu Bakr answered that the role would soften him.

He then had his choice written down and read to the people, who pledged to ’Umar.

Choose Check

Who ran the three days of consultation after ’Umar was stabbed?

  • ’Abd ar-Rahman ibn ’Awf
  • Mu’awiyah
  • Abu Hurayrah
Show the answer

’Abd ar-Rahman withdrew his own name, so the others trusted him to ask the people and decide.

Read

The council of six

A closed council-room door and three days marked on a calendar

Stabbed at the dawn prayer in 23 AH, ’Umar named six companions, all among the ten promised Paradise: ’Uthman, ’Ali, ’Abd ar-Rahman ibn ’Awf, Sa’d ibn Abi Waqqas, al-Zubayr and Talhah. They were to choose one of themselves within three days.

’Abd ar-Rahman stood aside and asked people across Madinah. Then he pledged to ’Uthman, and the people followed.

Go deeper: not his own son

’Umar let his son ’Abdullah sit with the council to advise, but ruled that he could not be chosen. A leader who keeps his own family out of the running leaves no room for talk of favour.

Guess

About thirty years

About how many years did the four rightly guided caliphs rule in all?

Show the answer

30 years About thirty years, 11 to 40 AH, with al-Hasan’s six months making it thirty.

Put in order

Put the caliphs in order

Put these in the right order.

  1. Abu Bakr
  2. ’Umar
  3. ’Uthman
  4. ’Ali
Show the answer

Abu Bakr, ’Umar, ’Uthman, ’Ali (radiyallahu ’anhum): the order of their caliphate, and for Ahl as-Sunnah also the order of their rank.

Match

Match the caliph to how he was chosen

Match each one with its pair.

  • Abu Bakr The Saqifah, then the pledge
  • ’Umar Named after consultation
  • ’Uthman A council of six
  • ’Ali Pledged to during a crisis
Show the answer

Four methods, one principle: consultation and the people’s pledge.

Reveal

Common mistakes

Flip each card: what people often get wrong, and what is right.

  • “Islam fixes one method for choosing a leader.” It fixes principles: consultation and the people’s pledge. The method changed four times.
  • “’Umar named his son to follow him.” He ruled that his son could advise but never be chosen.
  • “’Ali was picked by the council of six.” The council chose ’Uthman. ’Ali was pledged to in Madinah after ’Uthman was killed.

Read

For your life

A low round table with cushions and an open scroll: consultation before decisions

Your masjid committee, your family or your team will face big choices. Do it their way: ask the people it affects, let someone fair gather the views, keep your own relatives out of jobs you hand out, and once it is decided, support it.

Think about it

A heart moment

’Umar kept his own son out of the running. Where are you tempted to favour your own people over what is fair?

Only you can see this. It is kept on this device.

Reveal

The lesson in three lines

Sum up the lesson in your own words first, then tap to check.

  • The lesson in one line Four caliphs ruled for about thirty years, each chosen a different way. Abu Bakr at the Saqifah, ’Umar named after consultation, ’Uthman by a council of six, ’Ali by pledge in a crisis. The one principle behind them all was shura and the people’s bay’ah.

Lesson finished

Four caliphs, about thirty years

You added a century to a map whose borders change.

What you learnt

  • Four caliphs, four ways of choosing, one principle: consultation.

Your deed · Try it today

Consult someone before your next decision today.

Sign in to keep your progress on every device.