Why Scholars Differ, and How to Follow Your Madhhab Calmly · Beginner · Lesson 2/3 Why we follow one school

Step inside

Late, searching online

A pile of opinions

One video says one thing, another the opposite, a third mixes both. It is midnight and you just want to know how to pray.

Read

Following those who know

Eight book spines from al-Asl to Bahishti Zewar

Most of us cannot weigh evidence from the Quran, the Sunnah and Arabic ourselves. So we follow scholars who could, as the Quran tells us to ask those who know. Following a recognised school this way is called taqlid.

It is how Muslims have lived for over a thousand years: calmly, consistently, without reinventing fiqh every night.

Read

One school, consistently

Two books leaning on each other

Pick one school, usually your family's or your community's, and follow it consistently. Its rulings fit together like a well-made machine.

Taking the easiest view from each school, case by case, is not following any school: it is following your wishes. Changing school as a whole, for a sincere reason and with a teacher, is allowed.

Sort it

Following, or picking?

Sort each habit.

Following a school

  • Praying the Hanafi way and asking a Hanafi mufti
  • Changing school wholesale after study with a teacher

Picking the easiest each time

  • Taking one school for wudu and another for fasting because it's easier
  • Searching until you find a "yes"

Reveal

Common mistakes

Think of the right answer first, then flip each card.

  • "Following a school is blind." It is following those who knew, as the Quran tells us.
  • "I should work it out myself." Only qualified scholars weigh the evidence.
  • "Mixing gives the best of all." Mixing for ease follows desire.

Think about it

Pause and think

Have you ever searched for an easier answer? What would following one school consistently change for you?

Only you can see this. It is kept on this device.

Lesson finished

Why we follow one school

You added a key to a set of keys collected.

What you learnt

  • We follow scholars who knew: taqlid.
  • One school, consistently.
  • Change wholesale only for a good reason.

Your deed · Try it today

Find out which school your family follows, and one book or teacher of it you can ask.

Sign in to keep your progress on every device.