Envy and Contentment · Beginner · Lesson 2/3 Envy or a healthy wish?

Step inside

A row of back gardens

Over the fence

Your neighbour's garden is full of roses. Yours has a few brave daisies. You lean on the fence and look for a long time.

Look

Two gardens over the fence

Two gardens side by side over a low fence: the neighbour's full of flowers, yours with a few new seedlings and a watering can
Look at the neighbour's garden. Do you want to pull it up, or plant your own?

From the hadith

Two cases

وعن ابن مسعود رضي الله عنه عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم قال: "لا حسد إلا فى اثنتين: رجل آتاه الله مالاً، فسلطه على هلكته فى الحق، ورجل آتاه الله حكمة، فهو يقضي بها ويعلمها" ((متفق عليه)).

Ibn Mas'ud (May Allah be pleased with him) reported: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Envy is permitted only in two cases: A man whom Allah gives wealth, and he disposes of it rightfully, and a man to whom Allah gives knowledge which he applies and teaches it."

Agreed upon (al-Bukhari and Muslim) (متفق عليه) · Sahih

Read

What the hadith teaches

The only "envy" allowed is wishing for good like someone else's, without wanting it taken from them. Scholars call this ghibtah. The hadith names two people worth wishing to be like: one who spends wealth rightly, and one who has knowledge, acts on it and teaches it.

Read

Turning envy into ghibtah

Two gardens side by side over a low fence: the neighbour's full of flowers, yours with a few new seedlings and a watering can

When you feel the sting, turn it in five steps:

  1. Notice the feeling.
  2. Bless them: "May Allah bless it for them."
  3. Ask: how did they get there? What did they do?
  4. Make dua for them, and for yourself.
  5. Take one step towards that good in your own life.

The neighbour's roses become a reason to plant your own.

Go deeper: ghibtah in worldly things

Wishing for a lawful worldly thing like someone else's, without wanting theirs gone, is allowed. The scholars still say that contentment is better in worldly things. Ghibtah is most praised in the deen: knowledge, Quran, charity, good character.

Side by side

Hasad or ghibtah?

Feeling Hasad (envy) Ghibtah (healthy wish)
About their blessing Wish it gone from them Wish the same for yourself
What you do Criticise, avoid, hope they fail Ask Allah, work for it, learn from them
About the person Grudge Love and dua
Result Burns your good deeds Can become a good deed

Choose Which garden?

Which is ghibtah?

  • A hand-trowel digging up someone else's flowers Wanting your neighbour's flowers pulled up
  • A watering can over new seedlings Planting your own because you admire theirs
  • A tall wall blocking the view Building a wall so you never see them
Show the answer

Ghibtah plants your own garden; envy wants theirs destroyed.

Conversation

A friend who memorises fast

A friend from your Quran class who is ahead of you

  1. Alhamdulillah, I finished Juz 5 today!

    • Mabruk! How do you revise? I'd love to learn from you. Ghibtah turns admiration into learning. You wish for the same good without wanting hers taken away.
    • You must have lots of free time. A dig hides the sting of envy, and it spoils your friend's happy moment.
  2. I revise after Fajr for twenty minutes. Want to join me?

    • Yes, let's do it together. The wish became a good deed for both of you.
    • No, I'm fine. Not wrong, but you lost a chance to grow.

True or false True or false?

Wishing for a car like your friend's, without wanting his taken away, is envy.

TrueFalse
Show the answer

That is a healthy wish (ghibtah). Envy is wanting his blessing gone.

Tap the spot Your own garden

Ghibtah means tending your own garden. Tap the garden you should water.

Two gardens over a low fence: the neighbour's full of flowers, yours with a few new seedlings and a watering can
Show the answer

Your own, with the seedlings and the watering can. Admire the neighbour's garden, then work on yours: that is ghibtah.

What would you do?

Honestly

Whose good news is hardest for you to celebrate?

  • A brother or sister
  • A close friend
  • A colleague
  • Someone I only know online

Reveal

Common mistakes

Think of the right answer first, then flip each card.

  • "Ghibtah means I must have exactly what they have." Admire the good, then take your own step. Your path may look different.
  • Only admiring people for money and looks The best ghibtah is for knowledge, Quran and good character.
  • Hiding admiration because it feels like envy Tell them, and ask how they did it. That is ghibtah.

Read

A moment for the heart

Two gardens side by side over a low fence: the neighbour's full of flowers, yours with a few new seedlings and a watering can

When you see someone further along in their deen, it is a sign from Allah that the road is walkable.

Let their light show you the way, not dim your own.

Lesson finished

Envy or a healthy wish?

You added a leaf to a tree whose leaves grow.

What you learnt

  • Ghibtah: wishing for good like theirs, without wanting it taken from them.
  • The best ghibtah is for knowledge, wealth spent rightly, and good deeds.
  • Turn envy in five steps: notice, bless, ask, dua, act.

Your deed · Try it today

Name one person you admire for their deen, and ask them one question about how they do it.

Sign in to keep your progress on every device.