Checking a Hadith You See Online · مبتدئ · الدرس 3/3 What makes a report reliable

ادخل المشهد

A door with five locks

Five keys

Five keys on a ring. Only when all five turn does the door open: that is a sahih hadith.

انظر

When is a hadith sahih?

A balance beside a manuscript page, a bowl of dates under the window, by an arched window at dusk

Scholars agreed on five conditions. Like five keys, all must turn for the door to open.

Learn them once and every grade you see later will make sense.

اقرأ

In plain words

A balance beside a manuscript page, a bowl of dates under the window, by an arched window at dusk

A report is reliable when everyone who passed it on was honest and careful, each heard it from the one before, and nothing in it clashes with what is more certain.

Scholars checked all of this for us. Our part is to rely on their work: the trusted books and the teachers who know them.

Go deeper: the technical words

Scholars call a fully reliable report sahih, a reliable one a little below it hasan, and an unreliable one da'if. The full science of checking narrators is for specialists; this course keeps to what you need.

اعثر عليها

Five keys

Tap the picture to find each part. Each one opens a card.

Five gold keys on cards: a connected chain, upright narrators, precise narrators, no odd conflict with stronger reports, and no hidden defect
  1. Connected chain Each narrator heard it from the one before, with no gap.
  2. Upright narrators Every narrator has ʿadalah.
  3. Precise narrators Every narrator has dabt.
  4. No odd conflict It does not contradict a stronger report (shudhudh).
  5. No hidden defect No concealed flaw that experts can detect (ʿillah).

املأ الفراغ Fill the gap

A hidden defect that only experts can find is called an ______.

  • ʿillah
  • isnad
  • ijazah
أظهر الإجابة

'Illah. It is a concealed flaw that only experts can find.

اكشف

Common mistakes

Think of the right answer first, then flip each card.

  • "I can judge a hadith by how it sounds." Reliability depends on who passed it on, checked by scholars.
  • "Any old book makes it reliable." Use trusted collections and ask teachers.
  • "Scholars only guessed." They checked every link with great care.

انتهى الدرس

What makes a report reliable

أضفت زهرة إلى حديقة تنمو.

ما تعلّمته

  • Reliable: honest, careful narrators, each hearing from the one before.
  • Nothing in it clashing with what is more certain.
  • Rely on the trusted books and teachers.

عملك · جرّبه اليوم

Explain the five keys to someone who forwards hadith without sources.

سجّل الدخول لتحفظ تقدّمك على كل أجهزتك.